Coronary fistula is a rare form of congenital heart disease and is defined as an abnormal connection between a coronary branch and a cardiac chamber or a large intrathoracic vessel without the interposition of the capillary circulation. The right coronary artery is the most common site of origin for coronary fistula. Other sites include the left anterior descending artery and left circumflex artery. The clinical presentation and the natural history can be extremely variable depending on the patient ‘s age, fistula size, and anatomy. Small to medium-sized coronary fistulas may be asymptomatic. Large fistulas can manifest with angina pectoris due to myocardial ischemia secondary to the coronary steal phenomenon. Shunting through large fistulas can have hemodynamic consequences secondary to volume overload in the pulmonary or systemic circulation, leading to symptoms and signs of heart failure. We describe the case of an 83-year-old woman recently undergoing TAVI and suffering from primary myelofibrosis requiring periodic transfusions. Pre-TAVI coronary angiography showed coronary vessels free from significant hemodynamic lesions and multiple coronary-ventricular fistulas draining into the left ventricle. Total body aortic CT angiography did not reveal other abnormal vascular connections. One month after the aortic valve correction procedure, the patient presented with heart failure (HfpEF). At a recent follow-up visit, diuretic therapy was discontinued due to the successful correction of aortic valve disease and normal ejection fraction. Due to further anemization from the underlying hematologic condition, the patient underwent blood transfusion with worsening of dyspnea despite correction of hemoglobin levels. Discontinuation of diuretic therapy and transfusion of red blood cell units resulted in volume overload with worsening clinical condition. The presence of multiple coronary fistulas precluded an interventional approach, but therapeutic optimization and reintroduction of diuretic therapy restored the patient ‘s hemodynamic compensation. Usually fistulas drain into the low-pressure venous circulation like right ventricle and right atrium. This case represents a rare instance of multiple left coronary fistulas draining into the left ventricle (only 3% of cases). Aortic valve correction may have further reduced left ventricular telediastolic pressures, worsening the shunt of coronary fistulas resulting in heart failure due to volume overload